2024 BMW 1 Series vs. Audi A3 vs. Mercedes A-Class: Premium Hatchback Showdown

The premium hatchback segment for 2024 presents a tough choice among three titans of the automotive world: the BMW 1 Series, Audi A3, and Mercedes A-Class. Each offers compelling features, cutting-edge technology, and a premium driving experience, making them standout options for discerning buyers. In this detailed comparison, we explore their models, fuel options, specifications, pricing, and which one delivers the best value for money, driving experience, and comfort.

Models and Engine Options

BMW 1 Series (2024)

The BMW 1 Series retains its sporty character with three main engine options:

• Petrol: 118i (1.5L, 136hp) and M135i xDrive (2.0L, 306hp).
• Diesel: 116d (2.0L, 122hp) and 120d (2.0L, 190hp).
• Plug-in Hybrid: BMW hasn’t introduced a PHEV variant for the 1 Series yet, focusing on its internal combustion engines.

Audi A3 (2024)

Audi offers the A3 in a variety of configurations:

• Petrol: 35 TFSI (1.5L, 150hp) and S3 (2.0L, 310hp).
• Diesel: 30 TDI (2.0L, 116hp) and 35 TDI (2.0L, 150hp).
• Plug-in Hybrid: The A3 40 TFSIe combines a 1.4L petrol engine with an electric motor for a combined output of 204hp.

Mercedes A-Class (2024)

The A-Class lineup continues to impress with its versatility:

• Petrol: A200 (1.3L, 163hp) and AMG A35 (2.0L, 306hp).
• Diesel: A180d (1.5L, 116hp).
• Plug-in Hybrid: A250e, boasting 218hp with an all-electric range of up to 40 miles.

Exterior Design

• BMW 1 Series: Bold kidney grilles, sleek LED headlights, and dynamic proportions give the 1 Series a sporty stance. The M Sport trim enhances its aggressiveness with larger wheels and aerodynamic touches.
• Audi A3: Audi’s signature single-frame grille and sharp Matrix LED headlights create a refined and modern aesthetic. The S Line trim adds sporty flair with unique bumpers and side skirts.
• Mercedes A-Class: The A-Class exudes elegance with its minimalist grille, sculpted body lines, and LED lighting. AMG Line trims feature a sportier design with unique alloy wheels and aggressive styling.

Interior and Technology

BMW 1 Series

The 1 Series offers a driver-focused cockpit with:

• Infotainment: 10.25-inch touchscreen with BMW’s latest iDrive system.
• Comfort: Adjustable sport seats with premium upholstery options.
• Extras: A heads-up display and ambient lighting for an immersive experience.

Audi A3

The Audi A3 combines sophistication with practicality:

• Infotainment: 10.1-inch touchscreen with MMI Navigation Plus and Virtual Cockpit.
• Comfort: Ergonomic seats with Alcantara and leatherette trims.
• Extras: Bang & Olufsen sound system for audiophiles.

Mercedes A-Class

The A-Class cabin is a blend of luxury and tech:

• Infotainment: Twin 10.25-inch displays powered by the MBUX system with AI-driven voice control.
• Comfort: Multi-contour seats with optional massage functions.
• Extras: Advanced ambient lighting with 64 colors.

Driving Experience

• BMW 1 Series: Known for its agile handling and rear-wheel-drive feel (in select trims), it’s perfect for driving enthusiasts.
• Audi A3: Balanced and composed, with Quattro AWD available in higher trims for extra grip.
• Mercedes A-Class: Prioritizes comfort but doesn’t shy away from spirited driving, especially in AMG versions.

Value for Money

Petrol vs. Diesel vs. Plug-in Hybrid

• Petrol: The BMW 118i, Audi A3 35 TFSI, and Mercedes A200 deliver solid performance for city and highway use.
• Diesel: Ideal for long-distance drivers; the BMW 120d offers more power, while the Audi 35 TDI and Mercedes A180d are efficient but slightly underpowered.
• Plug-in Hybrid: The Audi A3 40 TFSIe and Mercedes A250e are excellent for short commutes with electric-only driving, though they come at a higher upfront cost.

Pricing

• BMW 1 Series: Starting at £31,500, rising to £44,500 for the M135i xDrive.
• Audi A3: Starting at £30,700, with the S3 topping out at £46,000.
• Mercedes A-Class: Starting at £31,200, with the AMG A35 priced around £45,000.

Best for Comfort

The Mercedes A-Class shines in terms of interior luxury, offering superior seat comfort and a quieter cabin. The ambient lighting adds an extra layer of elegance, making it the most relaxing ride.

Best Driving Experience

For enthusiasts, the BMW 1 Series delivers unmatched handling and responsiveness, particularly in the M135i xDrive. Audi’s Quattro-equipped A3 comes a close second, offering sure-footed confidence.

Best Value for Money

The Audi A3 strikes the best balance between cost and features, particularly in the plug-in hybrid variant. The BMW 1 Series offers better driving dynamics, but the A3 edges ahead in terms of versatility and overall appeal.

Conclusion

Choosing between these premium hatchbacks ultimately depends on your priorities. For spirited driving, go for the BMW 1 Series. If you want tech and a balanced package, the Audi A3 is hard to beat. For pure comfort and luxury, the Mercedes A-Class stands tall.

Explore the latest BMW, Audi, and Mercedes deals on our Carfundo Deals Page. For detailed reviews and pricing insights, check out Carwow.

Let Carfundo help you find the perfect premium hatchback that matches your needs. Contact us today!